Nimo

Choosing reaction pathways for efficient production

Quantitative chemistryYield and atom economy

Flashcards

Test your knowledge with interactive flashcards

Why can a pathway with lower atom economy still be chosen?

Click to reveal answer

A pathway with lower atom economy can be chosen if it gives higher yield, faster rate, valuable by-products or lower overall cost.

Key concepts

What you'll likely be quizzed about

Atom economy: definition and effect

Atom economy measures the proportion of reactant atoms incorporated into the desired product. High atom economy causes less raw material waste and fewer by-products, improving sustainability and reducing disposal costs. Formula: atom economy = (relative formula mass of desired product / sum of relative formula masses of all reactants) × 100%. Low atom economy causes large quantities of waste by-products that require treatment or disposal. Economic and environmental regulations favour higher atom economy for large-scale manufacture because lower waste reduces material costs and environmental liability.

Percentage yield: causes and limits

Percentage yield compares actual product obtained with the theoretical maximum. Formula: percentage yield = (actual yield / theoretical yield) × 100%. Low yields cause higher raw material use and higher cost per unit product. Reaction conditions, side reactions, incomplete conversions and losses during purification reduce percentage yield. Maximising percentage yield requires optimisation of reaction conditions and improved separation techniques. High percentage yield becomes critical when reactants are expensive or limited in supply.

Reaction rate and practical throughput

Reaction rate determines how quickly product forms and impacts production throughput. Fast reactions allow smaller reactors and higher output per unit time. Slow reactions require larger equipment and longer residence times, increasing capital and operating costs. Catalysts increase rate without being consumed and can change the practical viability of a pathway. Safety considerations arise when increasing rate through temperature or pressure, because harsher conditions can increase hazard and cost.

Equilibrium position and conversion limits

Equilibrium position determines the maximum conversion of reactants to products under given conditions. A position favouring products causes higher achievable conversion and higher theoretical yield. A position favouring reactants causes incomplete conversion and the need for recycling or shifting conditions. Le Chatelier’s principle predicts how temperature, pressure and concentration changes shift equilibrium. Shifting equilibrium towards products often requires trade-offs such as higher energy input or altered conditions that affect cost and safety.

Usefulness of by-products and circular economy

Useful by-products provide additional revenue streams and reduce waste disposal costs. A pathway producing valuable co-products can offset lower atom economy or yield. By-products that require complex separation or hazardous disposal reduce pathway attractiveness. Industrial selection favours pathways that produce useful by-products or that allow by-products to be recycled into the process. Market demand and regulatory constraints determine whether a by-product adds value or becomes a liability.

Trade-offs and overall evaluation

Choosing a pathway requires balancing atom economy, percentage yield, rate, equilibrium and by-product usefulness against cost, safety and environmental impact. A pathway with excellent atom economy but impractically slow rate or low yield may be inferior in practice. A fast, high-yield route with lower atom economy can be preferable if by-products are valuable and waste management remains feasible. Decision-making uses quantitative data together with practical constraints: raw material cost, energy input, separation complexity, regulatory compliance and scalability. The preferred pathway maximises net benefit per unit of product while meeting environmental and safety requirements.

Key notes

Important points to keep in mind

Atom economy focuses on atom usage; percentage yield focuses on actual output.

High atom economy reduces waste but does not guarantee high yield.

Reaction rate affects throughput and reactor sizing.

Equilibrium limits maximum conversion; shifting conditions changes achievable yield.

Usefulness or saleability of by-products can offset poorer atom economy.

Practical choice balances chemistry data with cost, safety and environmental impact.

Catalysts improve rate and sometimes selectivity without altering atom economy.

Purification losses reduce percentage yield and increase process cost.

Scale-up amplifies waste and hazard concerns, altering preferred pathways.

Quantitative comparison requires converting all factors into comparable metrics (cost, mass, energy).

Built with v0